Leading Without a Map
What can a leader steer in an institution that no one can fully command?
One book: Michael D. Cohen and James G. March, Leadership and Ambiguity: The American College President, 1974 · 5 min read
Every university president inherits an office that looks like command. Those who have held it know a quieter truth: no single person can steer a university.
This issue returns to a half-century-old study that described the university as an organized anarchy, with contested goals, uncertain methods, and shifting participants, and asked what wise leadership looks like inside it.
Its answer still holds. The task is not to eliminate ambiguity but to make it productive.
This issue features writing by Prof. Bassem Khafagy.
To those who dare to reimagine.

In this issue
This issue of Wisdom Forgotten turns to a single book and to the office at the center of every university, the presidency. Half a century after its publication, Michael D. Cohen and James G. March’s Leadership and Ambiguity remains one of the most candid accounts ever written of what it means to lead an institution that no one can fully command.
Prof. Bassem Khafagy reads the book as a guide for the present moment. Written for the Carnegie Commission on Higher Education, it described the university as an organized anarchy, an institution of contested goals, uncertain methods, and shifting participation, and it offered leaders a set of quiet, practical rules for acting wisely inside it. This week, the issue carries a single essay.
Read today, the book forms a single argument about leadership. Ambiguity is not a temporary failure that better planning will cure. It is the lasting condition of the university, and the leaders who will shape its future are those who learn to make it productive.
This issue of Wisdom Forgotten is dedicated, as always, to those who dare to reimagine.
The reading
The Presidency Without a Map:
What Organized Anarchy Still Asks of University Leaders
Prof. Bassem Khafagy
Reading: Leadership and Ambiguity: The American College President, by Michael D. Cohen and James G. March. 1974. 270 pages.
The Office Everyone Watches
Every university president inherits an office that looks, from the outside, like command. There is a title, a cabinet, a calendar full of ceremonies, and a board that can hire and dismiss. Yet anyone who has sat in that chair knows a quieter truth: the president is asked to steer an institution that no single person can steer.
Half a century ago, two scholars set out to describe that truth without flattery. Michael D. Cohen and James G. March published Leadership and Ambiguity: The American College President in 1974, as a general report for the Carnegie Commission on Higher Education, the body Clark Kerr chaired after he was dismissed as president of the University of California. Drawing on a study of presidents at forty-two American colleges and universities, they wrote one of the most honest books we have about the office.
The two authors came to the presidency as students of decision itself. James G. March, who spent most of his career at Stanford University, became one of the most influential thinkers on how organizations choose, learn, and remember. Michael D. Cohen, then early in a long career that later took him to the University of Michigan, brought the same curiosity about how institutions behave when no one is fully in charge.
Readers of this newsletter met Kerr in our seventh issue, where Christopher Washington revisited the multiversity, the institution Kerr himself likened to a city of infinite variety. Cohen and March took the next step. If the university is a city, they asked, what exactly does its mayor control?
An Organized Anarchy
Their answer begins with a phrase that still unsettles readers: organized anarchy. Universities, they argued, share three properties. Their goals are problematic, because members disagree about what the institution is for. Their technology is unclear, because no one can fully explain how teaching becomes learning or how inquiry becomes discovery.
Their participation is fluid, because faculty, students, trustees, and staff move in and out of decisions as their time and interest allow. None of this was offered as an insult. It was offered as a description.
Five decades later, the description has only grown more accurate. Universities now answer to more constituencies, operate across more platforms, and pursue more purposes than the campuses Cohen and March studied. The anarchy has grown faster than the organization, and the office at its center feels the strain first.
An institution with contested purposes, uncertain methods, and shifting participants does not make decisions the way textbooks of management assume. It makes them, as Cohen and March had shown with Johan Olsen two years earlier, more like a garbage can, where problems, solutions, people, and occasions for choice flow together and attach to one another partly by timing and partly by chance.
An institution with contested purposes, uncertain methods, and shifting participants does not make decisions the way textbooks of management assume.
The Illusion of Command
The book’s portrait of the president follows from this. In their account, the presidency is largely a reactive job, its attention claimed by the demands of others rather than by a plan of its own. Presidents spend their days answering, convening, and absorbing. The power they appear to hold is real in symbol and limited in substance.
This is not a counsel of despair. It is a correction of vanity. A leader who believes the office confers control will exhaust it chasing outcomes no office can deliver. A leader who understands the limits of control can spend the office’s real resources, attention, time, and meaning, where they matter most.
A leader who believes the office confers control will exhaust it chasing outcomes no office can deliver.
Rules for an Uncertain Room
The closing chapter turns from diagnosis to practice. Cohen and March offered eight tactical rules for leading in an organized anarchy, and several read today like advice written for this week. Spend time, because the person willing to invest hours in a decision gains an influence that formal authority alone cannot confer. Persist, because a proposal rejected today may return tomorrow in a different setting.
Exchange status for substance, letting others take credit while the work moves forward. Invite the opposition in, since participation tends to temper resistance more than exclusion does. Provide garbage cans, open forums where the institution’s restless problems can be aired without capturing every decision.
Even their most surprising rule, overload the system, carries a lesson. An institution flooded with proposals cannot block them all, and the patient leader learns which initiatives will survive the crowd. Influence in an organized anarchy belongs less to the loudest voice than to the most persistent one.
Manage unobtrusively, through small adjustments that let the system do much of the work. Above all, interpret history. Whoever writes the story of what the institution has decided shapes what it will decide next.
Whoever writes the story of what the institution has decided shapes what it will decide next.
The Case for Foolishness
The book closes on an idea that March would carry through the rest of his career, the need for what he called a technology of foolishness. Rational planning assumes that we already know our goals. Yet the most important goals are often discovered by acting, by playing with possibilities before they can be justified, and by treating our purposes as hypotheses to be tested rather than commandments to be defended.
This is where the book speaks most directly to the university now being born. Artificial intelligence, climate pressure, shifting public trust, and new ways of learning have multiplied the ambiguity Cohen and March described. No strategic plan can remove it. The task of leadership is not to eliminate ambiguity but to make it productive.
The task of leadership is not to eliminate ambiguity but to make it productive.
A Lineage of Honest Leadership
Cohen and March did not stand alone. Robert Birnbaum built on their work in How Colleges Work in 1988, placing the anarchical institution beside the collegial, the bureaucratic, and the political. Chris Argyris, whom Christopher Washington revisited in our fifth issue, showed how capable professionals defend themselves against learning.
Peter Eckel and Cathy Trower, the subject of our eleventh issue, asked boards to govern with judgment rather than habit. Eddie Cole, whose book I read in our seventh issue, reminded us that choices made in presidential offices echo far beyond the campus. Read together, these works describe one discipline, the exercise of judgment where rules run out.
That discipline is what the International Council for University Wisdom exists to cultivate. Leadership and Ambiguity gave it an honest map, by admitting that the territory could never be fully mapped.
Leading in the Fog
This week, negotiators from nearly every nation are gathered in Antalya, the city I call home, for COP31. Thousands of participants with competing goals, uncertain methods, and shifting attention are trying to reach decisions together. Cohen and March would recognize the scene at once, and they would remind us that the university is far from the only organized anarchy in the world.
Half a century on, their lesson stands. The president who waits for clarity will wait forever. The president who learns to lead through ambiguity, patiently, playfully, and with a clear sense of the story the institution tells about itself, can still move a university toward its better future.
The future of the university will not be commanded into being. It will be cultivated, one decision, one conversation, and one act of judgment at a time.

Prof. Bassem Khafagy, 12 November 2026
About the book
- Title
- Leadership and Ambiguity: The American College President
- Authors
- Michael D. Cohen and James G. March
- Publisher
- McGraw-Hill, New York, a general report for the Carnegie Commission on Higher Education; second edition, Harvard Business School Press, Boston, 1986
- Year
- 1974
- Pages
- 270 (first edition, xxiii plus 270); second edition xxi plus 298
- ISBN
- 0-07-010062-4 (first edition); 0-87584-131-7 (second edition, paperback)
- Recognition
- A Carnegie Commission on Higher Education report and the classic statement of the university as an organized anarchy
- Core Insight
- Cohen and March studied the American college presidency and found an office whose apparent authority far exceeds its actual control. They described the university as an organized anarchy, defined by problematic goals, unclear technology, and fluid participation. In such institutions, decisions rarely follow the orderly sequence that management theory assumes; problems, solutions, participants, and occasions for choice flow together, as in the garbage can model the authors had developed with Johan Olsen. The presidency, in their account, is largely reactive, its attention claimed by the demands of others. Rather than lament this, the authors offered practical rules for leading within it: spend time, persist, exchange status for substance, invite the opposition in, overload the system, provide garbage cans, manage unobtrusively, and interpret history. They also argued for a technology of foolishness, the deliberate playfulness that lets institutions discover goals they could not have planned. The result is one of the most candid and enduring accounts of academic leadership ever written.

