The Vocabulary

Every field has words that let its people see what others miss. These are fourteen of them, drawn from the canon of higher education scholarship. Each is a lens a university leader can carry into the next meeting.

Collage in gold: towers and script among tall blocks, a bare tree before them

Fourteen terms

  1. Organizational saga

    Burton R. Clark, 1970

    The shared story a college tells about its own unique achievement, rooted in a real moment of its history, embellished over time and held with something close to devotion. A saga is why a few institutions possess an identity that survives every leader, and why most never acquire one. It cannot be written by a communications office; it can only be earned and then kept.

  2. Elite, mass and universal

    Martin A. Trow, 1973

    The three phases a higher education system passes through as participation grows: elite while a small share of the age group enrolls, mass beyond roughly fifteen percent, universal beyond roughly half. Each phase changes what students expect, how curriculum is designed, how governance works and what a degree means. Many systems are run on rules written for the phase before the one they are in.

  3. Organized anarchy

    Michael D. Cohen and James G. March, 1974

    The university as an organization with unclear goals, uncertain methods and participants who come and go. Decisions in such a place often emerge when problems, solutions and people happen to meet, not through orderly planning. For a president, the insight is not despair but realism about where influence actually lies.

  4. The triangle of coordination

    Burton R. Clark, 1983

    Higher education systems are coordinated by three forces in different proportions: state authority, the market and the academic oligarchy of senior professors. Every national system sits somewhere inside that triangle. Reform that ignores where a system sits usually fails.

  5. Credential inflation

    Randall Collins, 1979

    As more people hold degrees, the degree buys less, and the response is to demand more degrees. Credentials can function as markers of status more than as proof of skill, which helps explain why educational expansion has not delivered the equality it promised.

  6. Cultural capital

    Pierre Bourdieu and Jean-Claude Passeron, 1970

    The knowledge, manners and familiarity with culture that some students inherit from their families and others must acquire. Schools and universities tend to reward this inheritance as if it were individual merit, and so reproduce social hierarchy while appearing neutral.

  7. Talent development

    Alexander W. Astin, 1985

    A definition of excellence that judges a college by how far it moves its students, not by the reputation it holds or the resources it accumulates. It asks the most uncomfortable question in higher education: what difference did we make?

  8. Student integration

    Vincent Tinto, 1987

    Students persist when they become part of the academic and social life of the institution, and leave when they do not. Departure is therefore less a verdict on the student than a measure of the institution’s own health.

  9. Academic tribes and territories

    Tony Becher, 1989

    Disciplines are cultures as well as bodies of knowledge, with their own values, rituals, ways of arguing and standards of proof. A university is a federation of such tribes. Leaders who treat faculty as a single body misunderstand the institution they lead.

  10. The four scholarships

    Ernest L. Boyer, 1990

    Scholarship has four forms: discovery, integration, application and teaching. When institutions reward only the first, they narrow the work of the professoriate and neglect what students and society most need from it.

  11. Mode 2 knowledge

    Michael Gibbons and colleagues, 1994

    Knowledge increasingly produced in the context of its application, across disciplines, by teams inside and outside universities, and accountable to society as well as to peers. The university no longer owns the production of knowledge, and must decide what it offers instead.

  12. Academic capitalism

    Sheila Slaughter and Larry L. Leslie, 1997

    The turn of universities and their faculty toward market and market-like behavior to secure revenue: patents, partnerships, fees, commercial research. Its gains are real, and so are its costs to the university’s public purposes.

  13. Supercomplexity

    Ronald Barnett, 2000

    A world in which not only the facts but the very frameworks for understanding them are contested and changing. The task of a university in such a world is to form people able to live and act amid uncertainty, not merely to transmit what is known.

  14. The multiversity

    Clark Kerr, 1963

    The modern university as a city of many communities, with many purposes and many constituencies, held together more by administration than by a single idea. Its president governs a federation, and the question the canon keeps asking is whether anything holds the city together beyond management.

Each term links to the issues and books where it is read in full. The vocabulary grows with the canon.