The Questions
University leaders do not arrive at a library by date. They arrive with a question. Here the Council’s reading is gathered by the questions it answers, each one linked to the issues that have taken it up and to the books in the canon still waiting to be read against it.

Eight questions
-
Question 01
What is the university actually for?
Every strategy, budget and accreditation report assumes an answer to this question, and very few state it. The canon has answered it many times, each answer shaped by its decade, and none of them is the answer of a mission statement.
Read in
Waiting in the canon
- The Emergence of the American University Laurence R. Veysey, 1965
- Not for Profit Martha C. Nussbaum, 2010
-
Question 02
What kind of human being should a university form?
Graduates leave with a credential. They also leave as a particular kind of person, whether or not anyone designed it. The question is whether the university will take responsibility for that formation or leave it to chance.
Read in
Waiting in the canon
- The Closing of the American Mind Allan Bloom, 1987
- The Real World of College Wendy Fischman and Howard Gardner, 2022
-
Question 03
Can a university renew itself without losing itself?
Institutions are built to last, which is exactly what makes them slow to change. The canon distinguishes between universities that transform from within and those that are transformed from outside, and the difference is rarely money.
Read in
Waiting in the canon
- The Distinctive College Burton R. Clark, 1970
- Sustaining Change in Universities Burton R. Clark, 2004
- The Innovative University Clayton Christensen and Henry Eyring, 2011
-
Question 04
What does the university offer when knowledge has left its walls?
Knowledge is now produced in laboratories, companies, platforms and machines. Expertise can be automated. What remains that only a university can give is the question of this decade.
Waiting in the canon
- Realizing the University in an Age of Supercomplexity Ronald Barnett, 2000
- Failure to Disrupt Justin Reich, 2020
- Robot-Proof Joseph E. Aoun, 2024
-
Question 05
What does a president owe beyond management?
The presidency can be run as an exercise in managing complexity. The canon asks whether it is also a moral office, and what happens to an institution when its leader treats neutrality as a safe place to stand.
Waiting in the canon
- Leadership and Ambiguity Michael D. Cohen and James G. March, 1974
- How Colleges Work Robert Birnbaum, 1988
- Universities in the Marketplace Derek Bok, 2003
-
Question 06
What happens to students after the door opens?
Admission is an announcement of intention. Whether students learn, stay and finish depends on what the institution builds after the welcome week ends.
Read in
Waiting in the canon
- Achieving Educational Excellence Alexander W. Astin, 1985
- How College Affects Students Ernest T. Pascarella and Patrick T. Terenzini, 1991
- Paying the Price Sara Goldrick-Rab, 2016
-
Question 07
What does a university reward without ever teaching it?
Some students arrive already fluent in what the university values: its manners, its references, its unspoken expectations. The institution then rewards that fluency as merit. The canon has named this for more than fifty years.
Read in
Waiting in the canon
- The Credential Society Randall Collins, 1979
- Homo Academicus Pierre Bourdieu, 1984
- Lower Ed Tressie McMillan Cottom, 2017
-
Question 08
Why do universities copy one another?
Every institution says it wants to be distinctive, and then it imitates the institution above it. This question has not yet been taken up in an issue. The books are waiting.
Waiting in the canon
- The Distinctive College Burton R. Clark, 1970
- The Enterprise University Simon Marginson and Mark Considine, 2000
- Rankings and the Reshaping of Higher Education Ellen Hazelkorn, 2015

