The Weight of the Institution
Why do universities absorb new technology and new expectations without changing how they work?
Two books: Justin Reich, Failure to Disrupt: Why Technology Alone Can’t Transform Education, 2020 and Richard Arum and Josipa Roksa, Academically Adrift: Limited Learning on College Campuses, 2011 · 7 min read
What if the institution itself is the quietest actor in every reform we have attempted?
Two books, a decade apart, ask that question from opposite directions. One examines what happens when powerful new technologies enter a university.
The other asks what happens to learning itself inside the same system. Their findings do not contradict. They complete each other.
This issue features writing by Dr. Christopher Washington and Prof. Bassem Khafagy.
To those who dare to reimagine.

In this issue
Two books, a decade apart, point to the same quiet actor in higher education. The institution itself. One asks why decades of educational technology have failed to produce the transformations their advocates predicted. The other asks why nearly half of undergraduates showed no measurable gains in learning after two full years of college.
Dr. Christopher Washington reads Justin Reich’s Failure to Disrupt, a careful account of why MOOCs, intelligent tutors, learning games, and the current wave of artificial intelligence have been absorbed into existing institutional patterns rather than reshaping them. Prof. Bassem Khafagy returns to Richard Arum and Josipa Roksa’s Academically Adrift, the longitudinal study that documented how undergraduate learning drifts inside a system producing the organizational outcomes it was designed to produce.
Read together, the two books form a single argument. Universities do not simply receive what comes to them. They absorb it. Technology, no matter how promising, is absorbed into the patterns of practice already in place. Learning, no matter how aspirational, drifts when the institutional architecture is organized around other priorities. The honest work is not adoption. It is redesign.
This issue of Wisdom Forgotten is dedicated, as always, to those who dare to reimagine.
First reading
The Question Behind the Technology:
Why Adoption Alone Does Not Transform the University
Christopher Washington, Ph.D.
Reading: Failure to Disrupt: Why Technology Alone Can’t Transform Education, by Justin Reich. 2020. 336 pages.
As a former university provost, I recall my inbox and voicemail being regularly filled with vendors offering the latest technological solution. Each promised something that seemed compelling on the surface: greater responsiveness to students and faculty, increased enrollment, improved student success, more efficient teaching, or better learning outcomes.
The temptation was always for me to ask, Can this technology do what it says it does? Justin Reich’s Failure to Disrupt: Why Technology Alone Can’t Transform Education suggests that university leaders should ask a more consequential question:
What would have to change in our institution for this technology to meaningfully improve education?
Reich examines several decades of the effectiveness of educational technologies including MOOCs, intelligent tutoring systems, automated assessment, learning games, and other large-scale digital innovations. He asks why so few have produced the transformational change their advocates predicted. His central insight is that technologies do not enter universities as independent forces. They are absorbed into existing institutional, instructional, cultural, and social systems.
His distinction matters to those interested in the effectiveness of higher education institutions. Universities are continually adapting curriculum, instructional practices, student services, faculty development, and operating processes in response to changing learners, professions, technologies, and societal expectations. A new platform can certainly improve efficiency or expand capability. But inserting new technology into the “old ways of doing things” does not necessarily lead to better results.
A new platform can certainly improve efficiency or expand capability. But inserting new technology into the old ways of doing things does not necessarily lead to better results.
Reich offers several important lessons for leaders navigating today’s enthusiasm around the adoption of artificial intelligence and other emerging technologies.
Educational innovations are often domesticated by existing systems.
Faculty norms, accreditation requirements, assessment practices, student expectations, business models, and organizational routines frequently shape how technologies are used more than the technologies reshape the institution. A university can introduce AI tutors, analytics, adaptive learning systems, and online platforms while leaving its underlying assumptions about curriculum, teaching, learning, and student support largely untouched.
Access to technology does not automatically produce equity.
Technologies described as more accessible or scalable may continue to disproportionately benefit learners who already possess academic preparation, social capital, confidence, time, and support. This point is particularly important for institutions serving students who lack one or more of these conditions, which potentially includes working adults, first-generation students, career changers, and learners balancing education with significant professional and family responsibilities. The leadership question is therefore not simply whether students have access to technology, but whether the surrounding educational system enables different kinds of learners to benefit from using it.
Our learning technologies are only as strong as the communities of educators who guide their use. (Reich, p. xi)
Transformation requires human infrastructure.
Technology operates within a learning ecosystem of faculty, instructional designers, advisors and support professionals, peers, feedback mechanisms, and learning communities. Reich therefore directs attention toward educator preparation and professional learning rather than assuming that the technology itself will produce better teaching. This is especially relevant as AI places increasingly powerful tools in the hands of both faculty and students. The educational value of AI tools will depend substantially on the capabilities of the faculty and students using them.
Leaders should be wary of “technological solutionism.”
Perhaps Reich’s most useful warning is against assuming that a technological innovation can substitute for the difficult work of institutional change. For university leaders, AI cannot by itself resolve deeper questions about curriculum relevance, workforce alignment, learning quality, student support, faculty roles, or educational equity.
AI cannot by itself resolve deeper questions about curriculum relevance, workforce alignment, learning quality, student support, faculty roles, or educational equity.
This is where I find Failure to Disrupt particularly valuable as a leadership resource. Its message is not that universities should resist new technology. It is that leaders should distinguish technological adoption from educational transformation.
During my years as an academic leader, the most consequential questions were rarely about technology alone. They were about whether our curriculum and support systems were adapting quickly enough to changes in learners, professions, society, and the ways knowledge was being created and applied. Technology could enable that adaptation, but I found that it has never served as a substitute for it.
The opportunity before higher education in the age of AI is not simply to incorporate more powerful tools into the university. It is to reconsider curriculum, teaching, faculty development, student support, assessment, and institutional processes in light of what these technologies now make possible, and what learners and society increasingly require from universities.
Technology may be a catalyst for transformation. But transformation occurs through the redesign of the educational system around learning, equity, professional relevance, human capability, and institutional adaptability.

Christopher Washington, Ph.D. 15 October 2026
About the book
- Title
- Failure to Disrupt: Why Technology Alone Can’t Transform Education
- Author
- Justin Reich
- Publisher
- Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts
- Year
- 2020
- Pages
- 336
- ISBN
- 978-0-674-08904-4
- Recognition
- A Science “Reading List for Uncertain Times” Selection
- Core Insight
- Educational technology has not failed because its tools were weak. It has failed because its evangelists mistook the classroom for a market, and the institution for an app. Reich examines three decades of learning at scale, instructor-guided, algorithm-guided, and peer-guided, and shows that each promising wave has been quietly domesticated by the complex political and pedagogical systems it was meant to disrupt. The future of learning technology, he argues, belongs not to the charismatic technologist but to the patient tinkerer, the educator who treats a new tool as an invitation to rethink practice rather than as a shortcut past the hard work of institutional change.
The other reading in this issue: The Drift Within: What a 2011 Study Still Demands of Higher Education ↓
Second reading
The Drift Within:
What a 2011 Study Still Demands of Higher Education
Prof. Bassem Khafagy
Reading: Academically Adrift: Limited Learning on College Campuses, by Richard Arum and Josipa Roksa. 2011. 272 pages.
A claim, well examined, can change the way an institution sees itself. In 2011, two sociologists offered such a claim about American higher education. It has not yet been answered.
Richard Arum, then professor of sociology and education at New York University and director of the Education Research Program of the Social Science Research Council, and Josipa Roksa, then assistant professor of sociology at the University of Virginia, set out to ask a question that universities had largely stopped asking themselves with rigor. How much are undergraduates actually learning during their time in college?
The book that emerged, Academically Adrift: Limited Learning on College Campuses, published by the University of Chicago Press, drew on transcript data, student surveys, and the Collegiate Learning Assessment, a longitudinal instrument administered to more than 2,300 students at twenty-four institutions in their first semester and again at the end of their second year.
The finding has lost none of its weight. For nearly half of the students studied, two years of college produced no statistically significant gains in critical thinking, complex reasoning, or writing.
The authors framed the conclusion plainly. They wrote that, for many undergraduates, the answer to whether they were actually learning much in contemporary higher education was, simply, not much.
That was not a polemic. It was a measurement.
A System Receiving What It Is Designed to Produce
Arum and Roksa did not present limited learning as an accident. They presented it as the predictable outcome of a system whose actors are receiving the institutional rewards they are organized to receive. Faculty are evaluated on research and publication. Administrators are measured by enrollment, retention, reputation, and fundraising. Students navigate a culture in which social engagement is honored more readily than academic effort, and grades have become largely insulated from the rigor of what was demanded.
In such a system, the authors observed, no actor is in crisis. Each is succeeding by the metrics that govern their work. The institutions are receiving the organizational outcomes they seek, and so the system, taken as a whole, is not threatened.
The drift is not a failure. The drift is the equilibrium.
The Conditions of Rigor
What makes Academically Adrift so durable is that it does not stop at diagnosis. The authors identify the conditions under which learning does occur. Students who took courses requiring more than forty pages of reading per week, and who wrote more than twenty pages over the term, demonstrated significantly stronger gains. Students who studied alone, rather than in unstructured groups, gained more. Students whose faculty held high expectations, demanded substantive work, and graded that work seriously outperformed their peers across institutional boundaries.
These findings are not romantic. They are operational. Rigor is a structural property, not a personal virtue. Where institutions arrange their courses, their staffing, and their evaluative norms around demanding intellectual work, learning follows. Where they do not, learning drifts.
A Conversation Already Begun
It is worth noting that Academically Adrift arrived in conversation with a generation of earlier work. Derek Bok had warned in Higher Learning (1986) that universities had failed to invest seriously in the effectiveness of their own teaching. Ernest Boyer, whose Scholarship Reconsidered we have visited in this newsletter, had documented in College (1987) the disconnection between curriculum, campus life, and the undergraduate experience. Vincent Tinto, whom we encountered last month, had shown how academic and social integration shape persistence.
Arum and Roksa stood on this lineage and, with the empirical force of a longitudinal instrument, made it impossible to look away. Yet the wider university, as the authors themselves acknowledged, did not reorder itself in response. The book sold widely. It was assigned in graduate courses. It earned the praise of public figures and the dismissal of others. And the institutional architecture it described continued, largely undisturbed, to produce the outcomes it had always produced.
Nearly a decade later, Justin Reich arrived with a parallel finding from an adjacent terrain. Reich asked why so many waves of educational technology, MOOCs, intelligent tutors, learning games, had failed to produce the transformational change their advocates had promised. His answer rhymed with Arum and Roksa’s. Technologies do not enter universities as independent forces. They are absorbed into existing institutional, instructional, cultural, and social systems. Arum and Roksa had documented a system producing the learning it was structured to produce. Reich showed that the same system absorbs new technology into the pattern of outcomes it was already structured to produce.
The two books form a single argument, separated by a decade.
What the Drift Tells Us About the Future
Reading Academically Adrift in 2026 is a different experience than reading it in 2011. The intervening years have brought a pandemic that displaced students from classrooms, an artificial intelligence that can now produce text indistinguishable from undergraduate essays, and a labor market that increasingly questions the credential itself.
Each of these pressures interrogates the same wound the book identified. If a college can pass through two years without producing measurable gains in reasoning and writing, what protects it now from technologies that can simulate those very competencies, or from employers who decide they no longer need the signal?
The answer cannot be defensiveness. It can only be design. Universities must be willing to measure what they say they teach, to align their incentives with what they say they value, and to make rigor the visible architecture of the undergraduate experience rather than its hopeful by-product.
The drift Arum and Roksa documented is not a closed chapter. It is the unfinished work of an institution still defining itself. Every university that takes this finding seriously is asked the same question, fifteen years later. What conditions must we now design so that the time students give us returns to them as something they can carry forward, into work, into citizenship, into a life shaped by the capacity to think well?
That is the question this book continues to ask. It awaits an institutional answer.

Prof. Bassem Khafagy, 15 October 2026
About the book
- Title
- Academically Adrift: Limited Learning on College Campuses
- Authors
- Richard Arum and Josipa Roksa
- Publisher
- University of Chicago Press, Chicago and London
- Year
- 2011
- Pages
- 272
- ISBN
- 978-0-226-02855-2
- Citations
- 4,500 to 5,500-plus (Google Scholar)
- Core Insight
- Universities are receiving the organizational outcomes they are structured to produce, and undergraduate learning is rarely among the prioritized outcomes. The institutional drift Arum and Roksa documented through longitudinal evidence is not a failure of any single actor but the predictable equilibrium of a system whose incentives, staffing patterns, and evaluative norms have moved away from rigorous instruction. Reversing the drift requires designing rigor as an institutional architecture rather than asking it of individual conscience.

