Wisdom … Forgotten · Issue 11 ·

Governing in the Future Tense

Can a university prepare its students for the future if those who govern it have stopped learning?

Two books: Peter D. Eckel and Cathy A. Trower, with a foreword by Richard Chait, Practical Wisdom: Thinking Differently About College and University Governance, 2019 and Alvin Toffler, Future Shock, 1970 · 9 min read

What happens when the future arrives faster than an institution can think?

Two books, nearly half a century apart, approach that question from opposite ends. One enters the boardroom, where good intentions can quietly harden into habit. The other names the pressure of change that arrives faster than people and institutions can absorb it.

Their findings meet in a single demand. A university that wants its students to learn, unlearn, and relearn must first learn to govern that way itself.

This issue features writing by Prof. Bassem Khafagy and Dr. Christopher Washington.

To those who dare to reimagine.

Collage of tall paper towers in tan and cream, with a small shield

In this issue

Two books, written nearly half a century apart, examine the same pressure from different vantage points. One enters the boardroom, where trustees decide what a university will become. The other names the force bearing down on that decision: change arriving faster than people and institutions can absorb it.

Prof. Bassem Khafagy reads Peter D. Eckel and Cathy A. Trower’s Practical Wisdom, a set of candid essays arguing that many boards underperform not through neglect but through habit, and that better governance begins with better thinking. Dr. Christopher Washington returns to Alvin Toffler’s Future Shock, the 1970 warning about too much change in too short a time, and asks what it now demands of universities preparing students for a world reshaped by artificial intelligence.

Read together, the two books form a single argument. An institution cannot prepare its students to learn, unlearn, and relearn if the people who govern it have stopped doing so themselves. Judgment, not procedure, is what allows a university to absorb the future without losing its purpose. The work ahead is to govern, and to teach, in the future tense.

This issue of Wisdom Forgotten is dedicated, as always, to those who dare to reimagine.

First reading

The Unfinished Boardroom:
What Practical Wisdom Still Asks of University Governance

Prof. Bassem Khafagy

Reading: Practical Wisdom: Thinking Differently About College and University Governance, by Peter D. Eckel and Cathy A. Trower, with a foreword by Richard Chait. 2019. 228 pages.

Every university has a room where its future is decided, and most of the people who live with those decisions will never enter it. Students do not sit there. Most faculty do not sit there. The trustees who do sit there meet a handful of times a year, read the materials they are given, and are asked to govern an institution whose daily life they rarely see.

That room is the subject of Practical Wisdom: Thinking Differently About College and University Governance, written by Peter D. Eckel and Cathy A. Trower, with a foreword by Richard Chait. The book began as a series of essays the authors wrote for Inside Higher Ed, and it carries the brevity and candor of that origin. It does not offer a manual. The authors present it as a book about how to think rather than how to do, and that distinction is the whole of its argument.

Their diagnosis is quiet and uncomfortable. Many boards do not fail through scandal or neglect. They underperform through habit, repeating practices that once seemed sensible and now produce little of value, while everyone in the room remains convinced that the work is being done.

A board can be busy, loyal, and well informed, and still fail to govern.

Diligence Is Not Governance

Eckel and Trower ask boards to look honestly at what they do with the scarce hours they have together. Too often those hours are consumed by reports received, committees heard, and motions approved, a rhythm that feels like oversight but leaves little room for the questions that matter. The authors ask whether a board is merely mediocre, and they mean the question seriously.

Their remedy begins with the quality of questions. A board that asks only whether the budget balances, whether enrollment met its target, or whether the campaign is on schedule is monitoring the institution, not governing it. Governing begins when a board asks what the institution is for, whom it is failing, and what it would have to change to fulfill its purpose more fully. Curiosity, in their account, is not a personal trait to be admired in individual trustees. It is a discipline the whole board must practice.

They give equal weight to what never appears on an agenda. Board culture, the unspoken norms about who speaks, who defers, and what may not be said, shapes decisions as powerfully as any bylaw. Power and influence move through relationships, above all the partnership between the president and the board chair, long before they move through votes. A board that never examines its own culture will govern according to rules it has never agreed to.

Mediocrity in a boardroom is rarely visible from inside it.

Why Practical Wisdom

The title is not ornamental. Aristotle distinguished knowledge of what is always true from phronesis, the practical wisdom required to act well in particular circumstances, where rules run out and judgment must take their place. Governing a university is precisely such a practice. No policy manual can tell a board when to defer to the president and when to press, when to protect a tradition and when to release it, or when a financial decision is also a moral one.

Eckel and Trower place that judgment at the center of trusteeship. They ask boards to hold themselves accountable, not only management. They ask that committees exist for a purpose rather than by inheritance. They ask that strategy be treated as more than a planning document, as an ongoing conversation about where the institution must go and what it must stop doing to get there. And they return to shared governance with the faculty, which, in my reading, is better understood as a source of institutional intelligence than as a constraint to be managed.

A Lineage of Governing Ideas

Practical Wisdom stands in a long conversation. In 1966, the American Association of University Professors, the American Council on Education, and the Association of Governing Boards issued their joint Statement on Government of Colleges and Universities, which framed governance as a responsibility shared among boards, administrations, and faculties. In How Colleges Work (1988), Robert Birnbaum showed that universities are loosely coupled systems, where authority is diffuse and leadership works through culture as much as through command.

Richard Chait, who wrote the foreword to this book, carried that conversation forward with William Ryan and Barbara Taylor in Governance as Leadership (2005). They argued that boards add the most value when they move beyond fiduciary and strategic work into generative thinking, the work of framing problems before solving them. Trower later translated that framework into practice for working boards. In Practical Wisdom, she and Eckel bring it to the scale of the ordinary boardroom, where generative thinking either happens on a Tuesday afternoon or does not happen at all.

Readers of this newsletter will recognize the thread. Clark Kerr described the multiversity as a community of competing interests held together by administration. Chris Argyris showed how organizations defend themselves against the learning they most need. Richard Arum and Josipa Roksa, whom we revisited last issue, documented a system producing exactly the outcomes it was organized to produce. Each of these findings eventually arrives at the same door.

Every finding about the university eventually arrives at the door of the room where its priorities are set.

The Board and the Pace of Change

This is where Practical Wisdom meets the book Christopher Washington revisits in this issue, Alvin Toffler’s Future Shock. Toffler warned in 1970 that the gravest danger of acceleration lies not in the pace of invention but in the human and institutional difficulty of absorbing change faster than it can be understood. Half a century later, that warning lands with particular force on the boardroom.

A board that meets a handful of times a year, reads what it is given, and approves what is placed before it is governing at the speed of a slower century. Artificial intelligence, shifting labor markets, and the new expectations of learners do not wait for the next committee cycle. When governance cannot interpret change, the institution experiences it as shock rather than as a question it is prepared to answer.

Toffler asked education to teach people how to learn, unlearn, and relearn. Eckel and Trower, in effect, ask the same of boards. A board that cannot set aside its inherited habits, question its own questions, and build new capacity will struggle to lead an institution through the very changes its students must master. Governance, too, must be conducted in the future tense.

What the Boardroom Must Become

The pressures now arriving at universities make the authors’ plea more urgent than when they wrote it. Demographic decline is reshaping enrollment. Artificial intelligence is altering what learning means and how it can be demonstrated. Public trust has thinned, and political attention to governing boards has intensified. In such a moment, a board that governs by habit is not merely inefficient. It is a risk to the institution it holds in trust.

The boardroom of the coming decade will need trustees who understand the academy as well as the balance sheet, who can sit with uncertainty without retreating into procedure, and who see their role as stewardship of a public good rather than supervision of an enterprise. It will need presidents who bring their hardest questions to the board rather than their most polished answers. And it will need boards willing to examine themselves with the same rigor they expect of the institutions they govern.

A board that governs by habit is not merely inefficient. It is a risk to the institution it holds in trust.

Eckel and Trower end by acknowledging that the work of governing is unfinished. That honesty is the book’s final lesson. Governance is not a structure to be completed but a practice to be renewed, one meeting, one question, one act of judgment at a time.

The universities that flourish in the decades ahead will not be those with the most elaborate governance charts. They will be those whose boards have learned to think, and whose thinking keeps pace with the future their students are entering.

Signature of Bassem Khafagy

Prof. Bassem Khafagy, 21 October 2026

About the book

Title
Practical Wisdom: Thinking Differently About College and University Governance
Authors
Peter D. Eckel and Cathy A. Trower, with a foreword by Richard Chait
Publisher
Stylus Publishing, Sterling, Virginia, co-published with Inside Higher Ed
Year
2019
Pages
228
ISBN
978-1-62036-839-8
Recognition
EAB Summer Reading Recommendation for College Presidents, 2019
Core Insight
Most boards do not fail dramatically. They underperform quietly, through habits that consume their scarce time without adding value. Eckel and Trower argue that better governance begins not with new structures but with better thinking, about the questions boards ask, the culture they sustain, and the accountability they impose on themselves. They treat curiosity as a collective discipline, the partnership between president and board chair as a hinge of institutional health, and strategy as an ongoing conversation rather than a document. Drawing on research on board dynamics, their consulting practice, and their own service as trustees, they write in short, provocative essays addressed to trustees and academic leaders. The result is less a manual than an invitation to practical wisdom, the judgment to govern well where rules run out.

The other reading in this issue: Alvin Toffler’s Forgotten Warning: Education Must Help Us Absorb the Future ↓

Second reading

Alvin Toffler’s Forgotten Warning:
Education Must Help Us Absorb the Future

Christopher Washington, Ph.D.

Reading: Future Shock, by Alvin Toffler. 1970. 505 pages.

Consider the different worlds in which today’s university leaders and their students have developed, or must develop, the capabilities required for professional success.

Like many university leaders today, I built a career through years spent in library stacks looking at journals, disciplinary specialization, professional experience, and relationships that established administrative and academic credibility and reputation. I believe that my success, like other academic leaders, reflected forms of knowledge that universities have long valued. These remain important foundations of academic and professional life.

However, the world awaiting today’s students and graduates operates under increasingly different practices and assumptions. Artificial intelligence (AI) is reshaping how work is performed, what constitutes professional expertise, and how quickly individuals are expected to demonstrate competence. Knowledge is more accessible, and technical skills can lose relevance more quickly, while career advancement may increasingly depend on the ability to work alongside intelligent technologies, exercise judgment under uncertainty, collaborate across disciplines, and continually acquire new capabilities. Graduates may be expected to assume responsibilities earlier in their careers while navigating professional roles that are themselves being rapidly redefined.

This presents university leaders with a difficult challenge. How do institutions whose traditions, practices, and leadership experiences were shaped by one set of assumptions prepare learners to succeed under another? The challenge is not to abandon the values and practices that have sustained universities, but to determine which should endure, which must evolve, and what new capacities students will need to thrive in a world of accelerating change.

How do institutions whose traditions, practices, and leadership experiences were shaped by one set of assumptions prepare learners to succeed under another?

This is why I believe Alvin Toffler’s Future Shock, published in 1970, deserves renewed attention by university leaders.

Writing in 1970, Toffler warned that the future does not arrive only as invention or progress. The future also appears as pressure. For Toffler, future shock is the result of “too much change in too short a time.” His concern was not simply technological change, but the human difficulty of absorbing change faster than people and institutions can make sense of it.

Toffler did not write primarily with universities in view. However, I believe that his warning speaks directly to higher education today. Artificial intelligence is reshaping professional work in the academy. Employers are revising expectations faster than many academic programs can adapt. Students are trying to translate degrees into uncertain career pathways. Faculty are being asked to redesign programs and course learning outcomes, assignments, and assessments as their own disciplines are changing. Staff are supporting learners whose lives and needs are increasingly complex. In this environment, the nature of accelerated change becomes part of the educational problem.

A university that emphasizes research activities may point forward in that sense, while leadership mindsets, governance, curriculum, advising, and curriculum review activities remain organized around assumptions of relative stability. So a university may produce new knowledge while still preparing students through models designed for a slower-paced world. As Toffler considered education in general, he believed learners would need the capacity to navigate novelty, revise assumptions, and act under uncertainty. He called this capacity “cope-ability.”

A university may produce new knowledge while still preparing students through models designed for a slower-paced world.

“By instructing students how to learn, unlearn and relearn, a powerful new dimension can be added to education.”

That idea is even more urgent in the age of AI. While students still need disciplinary knowledge, it is not enough when the tools, roles, industries, and expectations are changing rapidly in ways that impact the discipline. Learners need structured opportunities to encounter ambiguity, test assumptions, use technology responsibly, make judgments with incomplete information, and connect knowledge to changing professional demands. Learning pathways can help learners move from knowledge to competence, and from competence to adaptive judgment.

I realize from experience that the redesign of learning ecosystems is not easy work. For example, some forms of institutional stability such as faculty judgment, careful curriculum design, creating assessments that align with learning outcomes, and traditions still give people purpose and learning its depth. But university leaders should be careful not to confuse slowness for seriousness. When delay leaves students underprepared, programs misaligned, or institutions unable to respond to the world learners are entering, stability becomes the institution’s burden, or, worse, its negligence.

University leaders should be careful not to confuse slowness for seriousness.

This is the leadership challenge that Toffler helps us see.

Future Shock names the human problem of living through rapid change without adequate preparation, interpretation, or support. Education can help learners understand what is changing, decide what still matters, and build the capacities within them to successfully adapt to change.

Perhaps this is a future-facing purpose of universities today: to help society absorb acceleration without losing judgment, purpose, or coherence. Universities do this when they translate evolving roles into learning pathways that learners can easily navigate, connect knowledge and its application to changing professional demands, and cultivate habits of mind that allow learners to learn, unlearn, and relearn.

A future-facing purpose of universities today is to help society absorb acceleration without losing judgment, purpose, or coherence.

For Toffler, education had to stop facing backward and shift into the “future tense.”

In the rapidly changing world that university graduates face, that wisdom is a current leadership responsibility.

Signature of Christopher Washington

Christopher Washington, Ph.D. 21 October 2026

About the book

Title
Future Shock
Author
Alvin Toffler
Publisher
Random House, New York
Year
1970
Pages
505
ISBN
0-394-42586-3 (first edition)
Recognition
International bestseller; more than six million copies sold within five years of publication, and translated into some twenty languages
Core Insight
Toffler argued that the defining danger of the modern era is not change itself but its acceleration, the arrival of too much change in too short a time for individuals and institutions to absorb. He gave the resulting disorientation a name, future shock, and traced it through transience in work, relationships, and things, through novelty in science and culture, and through the overwhelming diversity of choice. His remedy was not to halt change but to build the human capacity to meet it, which he called cope-ability. Education stood at the center of that remedy. Schools, he warned, were still facing backward toward an industrial past, and he called for education in the future tense, one that would teach people to learn, unlearn, and relearn. Half a century later, in an age of artificial intelligence, his diagnosis reads less as prediction than as description.

Prof. Bassem Khafagy is Co-Founder and Chairman of ICUW. (October 2026)

Dr. Christopher Washington is Co-Founder and President of ICUW. (October 2026)

All issues →